Loading The Good HOA…

This is taking longer than expected.

The page may have failed to load. Try reloading — if it keeps happening, that's on us and we want to know.

Email support@thegoodhoa.com  ·  Reload the page

How to Run an HOA Election Residents Trust

An HOA election that residents trust is the foundation of every other thing the board tries to do. If residents believe the election was fair, the board has a real mandate. If residents suspect the election was stacked, every decision that comes after is contested — including ones nobody would otherwise object to. The election is where legitimacy is earned or lost.

Here's the process self-managed HOAs use to run elections that hold up legally, look fair to residents, and produce boards that can actually govern.

What separates trusted elections from contested ones

The differences aren't subtle. Trusted elections have published timelines, clear candidate procedures, secret ballots, independent counting, and documented results. Contested elections have ad-hoc nominations, "show of hands" voting, ballots collected by the incumbent board, and results announced verbally with no written record. Residents notice both extremes.

The good news: running a trusted election doesn't cost much more than running a sloppy one. The work is mostly procedural — once the procedure is in place, repeat it every year.

Step 1: Publish the election timeline 60 days in advance

Every important date goes out in a single notice to all residents 60 days before the election. Nomination window opens [date]. Nomination window closes [date]. Candidate statements due [date]. Ballots mailed [date]. Voting deadline [date]. Counting and announcement at [date].

The timeline serves two purposes. First, it gives potential candidates real time to consider running — most residents won't decide to run if they learn about the election a week before nominations close. Second, it removes any later argument that the process was rushed or hidden.

Step 2: Run an open nomination process

Any owner in good standing should be able to nominate themselves or another owner. The nomination form is simple: name, unit, brief candidate statement (200 words max), and signature. Nominations go to a non-incumbent (the secretary works, or a non-board volunteer) to remove any suggestion the incumbents are filtering.

Reject only on documented criteria: not an owner, not in good standing, multiple unit conflict of interest disclosed but not resolved. Don't reject on subjective grounds like "we don't think they'd be a good fit." That's how elections get contested.

Step 3: Distribute candidate information uniformly

Every candidate gets the same word count for their statement. The statements go out together, in alphabetical order, in the same email/mailing. No candidate gets a separate "endorsement from the current board." If the board has a position, it goes out as its own communication, clearly labeled as such, and only after the candidate statements have been distributed.

Step 4: Secret ballot or nothing

Show-of-hands voting at the AGM is the single most common source of contested HOA elections. Residents who voted for the losing candidate suspect (often correctly) that the count was approximate. Tally errors are common. Late arrivers don't get to vote. Residents who couldn't attend get no voice.

The right answer is a secret ballot — mail or electronic — with a clear voting window. Each owner gets one ballot per unit. Ballots are anonymous. Voting can happen in person at the AGM or remotely.

Step 5: Independent counting

The board doesn't count its own election. A non-board committee, an outside service, or volunteer non-board members handle counting. Two counters minimum, both watching each other, results reconciled before announcement. Sealed ballots opened only when both counters are present.

For boards under 50 units, this can be two neighbors who volunteer. For larger associations, an outside election service ($300-500 for a simple election) is worth the credibility.

Step 6: Announce results with the count

"Smith won" isn't an announcement — it's an assertion. The announcement should include: total ballots received, total ballots invalidated and why, vote count for each candidate, and the names of who counted. If the count is close, the announcement should specifically note that — residents notice when boards try to obscure narrow margins.

Document retention

Keep the ballots (sealed) for at least one year after the election. State law varies, but a year is the minimum that protects the board if a result is later challenged. After the retention period, dispose of ballots securely (shred), but keep the counted totals and the official result indefinitely.

The most common election mistakes

For the broader AGM that the election happens at, see AGMs that don't waste 3 hours of everyone's Saturday. For when residents try to challenge a board, see How to handle a board recall petition without breaking the bylaws.